The violinist Emanuel Hurwitz, who has died aged 87, was one of
Britain's leading chamber musicians. Few string players carved a
career without either overlapping or bumping into Hurwitz, either as
a player in his various ensembles or as a highly influential
teacher, and he became one of the most respected violinists of the
half century following the second world war.
Always immersed in chamber music, for which he had an empathy
both in playing and teaching, there is no doubt that had he
practised with a soloist's career in mind, he could have been one of
the foremost violinists of his time. But this was not his chosen
way, and he liked a quiet life with his colleagues, his natural
musicianship helped by a terrific technique and an effortless
understanding of style.
It was as a leader that Hurwitz found his playing and personal
strengths most happily employed, his quiet tact and good humour
always calming any troubled waters. Never one for losing his temper
or throwing his weight about, and invariably friendly to those
around him, he would always see the funny side of some impossible
situation - often involving the notorious egos of conductors and
soloists - and was able to dig his fellow musicians out of whatever
hole they were in, often with large lashings of his incredible
humour.
He was held in such respect that his tactics rarely failed. These
outstanding leadership qualities were combined with the strengths of
his fiddle playing, not least of which was the most gorgeous sound
he created on his treasured 1603 Amati instrument.
Born in Aldgate, east London, with both parents of Russian-Jewish
ancestry, Hurwitz was given a violin outfit for his fifth birthday,
and had lessons first with a local teacher, Hilda Morris, going on
after two years to Leon Bergman, whose pupils included the fine
violinist Albert Sandler. In Riki Gerardy's absorbing book, Talks
With Emanuel Hurwitz: 82 Years With the Violin, Hurwitz referred to
a supportive family background, his father phlegmatic but his mother
unpredictable, becoming hysterical if she thought he had not done
enough practice. "She would curl up a plait in each hand and bang
her head against the wall a few times, screaming that I was the son
of the devil, before collapsing into a chair and sighing 'Oi veh!'."
Hurwitz was always a natural player and found the instrument
relatively easy, certainly in comparison to school work, taking up a
scholarship from a friend of Bronislaw Huberman at 14 to the Royal
Academy of Music, where his studies included learning with the
Australian Sydney Robjohns. This was his first introduction to the
central-European, Viennese-Hungarian way of playing, as Robjohns had
attended classes with the Joachim Quartet, whose leader, Joseph
Joachim, had been close to Brahms and Dvorak.
The second world war interrupted Hurwitz's career with a spell in
the Royal Army Medical Corps. He joined the band, based at the
headquarters in Fleet, Hampshire. In 1943 he was bound for the
Middle East, playing in any place recently occupied by the British,
and returned to London in 1944 to spend the last few months of his
service playing in a group called Stars in Battledress, which was
filled with musicians such as William Pleeth and Frederick Riddle.
After the war, Hurwitz found himself playing quartets, his early
chamber colleagues in the Hurwitz String Quartet (1946-51) also
becoming members of the English Chamber Orchestra (ECO) when it was
founded in 1948 (initially, it was known as the Goldsborough
Orchestra). Hurwitz became leader of the ECO and held the position
for 20 years, presiding over a group in which the string playing was
without peer.
He also led the Melos Ensemble (1956-72), then one of the most
stylish of such groups in Europe, and many famous recordings were
made, including the Beethoven Septet, the Schubert and Mendelssohn
Octets, and Schubert's Trout Quintet. The Melos collaborated on many
occasions with Benjamin Britten, as in the celebrated 1963 recording
of the War Requiem with the London Symphony Orchestra; Britten also
regularly consulted Hurwitz about technical aspects of the fiddle
parts in his writing (and he conducted Hurwitz and the ECO in the
recording of Bach's six Brandenburg Concertos for Decca).
In 1969, Hurwitz became leader of the New Philharmonia Orchestra.
Never having led a symphony orchestra, he was curious to see what it
would be like to lead 100 people instead of 25 - and what it would
be like leading for Otto Klemperer at the age of 80. Then, in 1970,
he joined the Aeolian String Quartet as leader, encouraged by his
old friend Raymond Keenlyside, whom he had known since the
Goldsborough days, to take over the first chair from Sydney
Humphreys. This was the quartet's last incarnation, with Keenlyside
(second violin), Margaret Major (viola) and Derek Simpson (cello):
it lasted until the group disbanded in 1981.
In particular, the quartet will be remembered for its recording
of the complete Haydn string quartets (the project was the main
incentive for Hurwitz to join the group), an undertaking completed
in 1976, since when it has reappeared on CD, over 22 discs. In 1975,
they performed the late Beethoven quartets on BBC television, in a
series recorded at Heveningham Hall, Suffolk, and later recorded
these works on disc.
Joining the quartet had necessitated leaving the New Philharmonia
in 1971, but the variety of Hurwitz's activities never completely
eclipsed his love of the chamber orchestra, a medium which gave him
occasional scope as a concerto soloist. He recorded the Holst Double
Concerto with Kenneth Sillito (conducted by Imogen Holst). In 1968
he formed the Hurwitz Chamber Orchestra, which he led without the
aid of a conductor; from 1972 onwards, it appeared as the Serenata
of London.
For many years Hurwitz was a professor at the RAM, and then
taught a stream of students at home; his aim was to encourage
players to make a first-class sound, and never be deterred by
technical problems, for which he had a wide repertory of solutions.
He was an influential member of the European String Teachers'
Association, and conducted children and students after his wife Kay
started Youth Music in Hampstead, as well as in summer courses and
as a visiting teacher at specialist schools. In 1978, he was made a
CBE.
He was also a well-known figure at London's instrument auctions,
particularly when it came to buying bows, an area in which he could
offer students reliable advice. Throughout his life he retained an
enthusiasm for music and teaching which he never stopped conveying
to others. He leaves Kay, his cellist son Michael, and stepdaughter
Jackie, from Kay's first marriage.
Christopher Driver writes: By luck, I knew Manny and his
family of musicians for some 25 years; I was also invited to meet
the Aeolian players and listen to them all talking separately about
each other. Apart from the finished Haydn records and musicians'
reminiscences, relaxed conversation was the only way to convey the
unmistakable particularity of the man. In addition to attending the
RAM, he had studied with Bronislaw Huberman, the extraordinary
soloist whose imagination could conjure up notes capable of "wrong"
intonation and make them more interesting. Hurwitz had the same
gift, according to a few wicked critics.
Margaret Major, the violist, said: "Manny was one of those very,
very rare violinists who is highly conscious of the variation within
all kinds of music." Yes - and he used words with equal variations.
A note I made of an Aeolian Quartet rehearsal includes Manny saying:
"It's Moth's [Major's] tune. It's not a question of the others
playing more softly but of being a bit woollier while she's ridgier.
A nice woofle underneath her."
Similarly, Raymond Keenlyside described Manny as "a person who
remembers what it was like to be hungry when he was young and
cannot, ever, stop eating too quickly. He came and played with us
for a whole evening after we had lost our leader suddenly, which had
left us in the lurch. We didn't need more than that evening. We were
very lucky. The difficulty was to pin Manny down, because he had
many talents, with fingers in many pies."
Manny read voraciously, and talked about many things apart from
music. But he was absolutely fascinated by everything to do with
fiddles and fiddle-playing. Keenlyside said: "He once told me that
occasionally, in the middle of the night, he'd take a couple of bows
by the same maker and just sit and look at them till he felt he knew
how the man did it.
"And I remember one afternoon in Sydney. He'd got it into his
head that a dealer's particular bow might be by the maker Tubbs.
Manny was there for three hours. He must have tried every fiddle in
the shop. He didn't ask to try the bows, because then the dealer
would have known what he was after. He tried the fiddles, which he
was not interested in at all, and kept picking up different bows to
play them with until he came round to the one he wanted. Then he
decided it wasn't a Tubbs bow and came away. He was the most
generous person in all sorts of ways, but getting a Jewish bargain
is like a game you play, watching every move."
· Emanuel Henry Hurwitz, violinist, born May 7 1919; died
November 19 2006